JH Like Aznick stated the poping in the shoulder should not be too common unless there is significant weakness and this should not be the case at 5 months. The shoulder subluxing is definitely not OK. What exactly did your daughter have done?? Did they tighten the joint or was any laxity noticed beore?

You need to get that repeat MRI/arthrogram, given that eary incident of passing out on the shoulder. Also if your OS or PT are not giving you consistent answers go to another. The whole purpose of the the surgery is to get back to the previous level of activity so try to ascertain whether the repair has held and or what is going on. Sharon